Skip to content

Imperialists circling Syria the Kurdish struggle and Germany in crisis AGAINS

Against The Stream · 2025-01-03

Here is the structured analytical summary of the Against the Stream podcast episode, "Imperialists circling Syria the Kurdish struggle and Germany in crisis."

Core Argument

The central thesis of this episode is that the global capitalist system has entered a terminal phase of crisis, manifesting simultaneously as imperialist barbarism in the Middle East and political-economic decay in the heartlands of Europe. The argument claims that the collapse of the Assad regime in Syria is not a spontaneous event but a deliberate, coordinated operation by US imperialism, executed through jihadist proxies and mercenaries, to destabilise the region and strike at rivals (Russia and Iran). This is presented as a stark illustration of the "socialism or barbarism" dilemma. Concurrently, the crisis of German capitalism—marked by de-industrialisation, falling living standards, and the collapse of the traditional party system—demonstrates that the system can no longer deliver even the basic material conditions for the working class in the advanced economies. The episode argues that the rise of right-wing populists (AfD, Reform UK, Le Pen) is a symptom of this crisis, not a solution, and that the only genuine alternative is the construction of a revolutionary communist party capable of channelling the growing class anger into a socialist transformation.

Theoretical Grounding

The analysis is rooted in the classical Marxist tradition, specifically the Leninist theory of imperialism and the Marxist critique of political economy. The episode draws on:

  • The Leninist theory of imperialism as the highest stage of capitalism: The US is not acting out of malice but out of the systemic need to dominate markets, secure strategic corridors, and weaken rival imperialist blocs (Russia, Iran). The use of jihadist forces (HTS) and mercenaries (the "Revolutionary Commando Army") is understood as a standard imperialist tactic of using local proxies to achieve geopolitical ends, echoing interventions in Libya and Iraq.
  • The critique of reformism and opportunism: The Kurdish leadership (SDF/PYD) is criticised for its "pragmatic" alliance with US imperialism. The argument draws on Engels’ critique of "practical politics" – the idea that sacrificing long-term class interests for short-term tactical gains (US protection) leads to strategic defeat. The Kurdish project is seen as a case study in the impossibility of "socialism in one region" without breaking decisively with imperialism.
  • The tendency of the rate of profit to fall and the crisis of overaccumulation: The crisis of German capitalism is explained not as a cyclical downturn but as a structural crisis. German capital has failed to invest in new industries (electric vehicles, AI) and has instead relied on squeezing the working class (Agenda 2010 reforms, wage suppression) and external factors (cheap Russian gas, the Chinese market, a diluted Euro). This is presented as a classic case of a mature capitalist economy hitting the limits of its accumulation model, leading to de-industrialisation and a political crisis of legitimacy.
  • The concept of the "dead end of capitalism": The episode repeatedly uses this phrase to argue that the system can no longer offer a progressive path forward. In Syria, it offers only civil war and sectarian fragmentation. In Germany, it offers only austerity and a falling standard of living. The only way out is the revolutionary expropriation of capital.

Conjunctural Relevance

The episode is highly specific to the conjuncture of late 2024 and early 2025.

  • Syria and the "Domino Effect": The analysis directly connects the collapse of the Assad regime to the ongoing Israeli assault on Gaza and Lebanon. The Rampage of Israel is described as having "started a domino effect" that destabilised the entire region. The episode cites specific, recent events: the US diplomatic mission to HTS leader al-Jolani, the removal of the $10 million bounty on his head, the rapid expansion of the US-run al-Tanf base, and the Israeli destruction of 70% of Syria's strategic military equipment. The argument is that the US and Israel are deliberately ensuring Syria remains a "failed state" to prevent any centralised power from emerging.
  • The Kurdish Predicament: The episode captures the immediate post-Assad crisis for the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF). It notes the Turkish-backed attacks on Manbij, the SDF's negotiations with HTS, and their appeals to Israel. The analysis is that the Kurds are being cornered and that their reliance on the US has left them isolated and vulnerable to betrayal.
  • The German Crisis: The episode grounds the political crisis (the collapse of the coalition government, the rise of the AfD to 18% in polls) in concrete economic data. It cites a 20% fall in industrial production since 2017, a loss of €210 billion in investment since 2020, and a 10% drop in real wages below the pre-crisis trend. The "de-industrialisation" of Germany is linked directly to the loss of cheap Russian gas and Chinese competition in the auto sector. The episode correctly identifies that the ruling class's only answer is a new wave of austerity and attacks on the working class, which is the material basis for the rise of the AfD.

Where the Argument Continues

This episode is a current affairs snapshot, and its arguments are developed across the broader RCI corpus.

  • The nature of the Syrian state and the Assad regime: The episode references a longer article on marxist.com about the "nature of the Assad regime and the process it had gone through" (privatisation, corruption). This is a key thread in the RCI's analysis of the "dead end of capitalism" in the region.
  • The Kurdish "experiment" and the critique of "democratic confederalism": The episode's critique of the Rojava project is a recurring theme. It is developed in depth in other Against the Stream episodes and in theoretical articles on marxist.com that critique the PKK's ideology as a form of petty-bourgeois radicalism that avoids the question of state power and the expropriation of capital.
  • The crisis of the European Union and the German model: The analysis of Germany as the "powerhouse" of Europe that is now fragmenting is a central plank of the RCI's analysis of the global crisis. This is explored in episodes on the French crisis, the Italian elections, and the collapse of the British economy.
  • The "Luigi Mangione moment" and the radicalisation of youth: The episode briefly references the widespread sympathy for the killing of a CEO in the US as evidence of "tremendous class anger." This is a key conjunctural observation that the RCI is developing into an argument about the potential for a rapid shift from populist anger to revolutionary consciousness, provided a communist pole exists.

Connections

  • Lenin, Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism: The theoretical foundation for the analysis of US intervention in Syria.
  • Engels, "The Tactics of Social Democracy" (Critique of the Erfurt Programme): The episode's critique of "pragmatic politics" and the danger of sacrificing long-term class interests for short-term gains is directly drawn from Engels' warnings against opportunism.
  • Karl Marx, Capital, Volume 3 (The Tendency of the Rate of Profit to Fall): The underlying structural logic for the German crisis, though not named explicitly, is the falling rate of profit and the consequent drive to squeeze the working class.
  • Other Against the Stream episodes: Episodes on the war in Ukraine, the crisis of the French state, and the rise of the far-right in Europe are essential companion pieces that develop the same themes of imperialist rivalry and the political crisis of bourgeois democracy.
  • Articles on marxist.com: The episode repeatedly directs listeners to the website for more detailed economic analysis, particularly on the German crisis and the history of the Syrian state.

Key Quotes

  1. "What we really see in Syria is a complete dead end of capitalism... the idea that Russia or Iran... can solve this situation... they cannot solve any of the problems and they do not have the interests of the Middle Eastern masses at heart."
  2. "You cannot Ally yourself with a class enemy... you can tie yourself to the interests of a class enemy least of all the most reactionary force that has ever existed on this planet."
  3. "The answer to the crisis of German capitalism is to further deepen the attacks on the German working class... it means an assault on the working class at all levels."
  4. "The working class has to go to the school of these people [the populists] unfortunately... but the working class does learn... it draws conclusions from this experience that will be the next phase."
  5. "It's never been easier being a communist... because the system is going into a crisis and in one country after another the class struggle is beginning to accelerate."