Skip to content

Capitalism a history of horror without end

Marxist Theory · 2017-04-13

Core Argument

The article argues that capitalism is not a system that has occasionally produced horrors as aberrations or excesses, but one whose normal functioning generates systematic violence, exploitation, and destruction. The central claim is that the barbarism associated with capitalism — from colonial genocide to fascism to imperialist war — is not a departure from capitalist civilisation but its logical and necessary expression. The article rejects the notion that capitalism has become more humane over time, insisting that the same predatory logic that drove primitive accumulation continues to operate, albeit in modified forms, in the present conjuncture.

Theoretical Grounding

The analysis is rooted in historical materialism, drawing on Marx's account of primitive accumulation in Capital Volume I — the violent expropriation of direct producers that cleared the ground for capitalist relations. It extends this into an analysis of imperialism in the Leninist tradition, treating the drive for markets, raw materials, and spheres of influence as inherent to capitalism's expansionary logic. The article also deploys Trotsky's theory of uneven and combined development to explain how capitalism reproduces barbarism at the periphery while presenting itself as civilised at the centre. The theoretical thread is that capitalism's "civilising mission" is a mask for a system that can only function through periodic convulsions of violence, whether against nature, labour, or rival capitalist states.

Conjunctural Relevance

Written in 2017, the article situates its argument in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis and the austerity regimes that followed across Europe. It points to the Greek debt crisis as a contemporary example of capitalism's brutality — the imposition of devastating conditions by the Troika on a democratically elected government that dared to challenge neoliberal orthodoxy. The article also references the rise of far-right movements, the refugee crisis in the Mediterranean, and the intensification of imperialist rivalries, particularly around Ukraine and the Middle East. It argues that these are not signs of a system in crisis but of a system being itself — that the horror is not exceptional but structural.

Where the Argument Continues

The article is part of a broader IDOM corpus that develops the case for revolutionary defeatism and the impossibility of reforming capitalism. It connects to Fred Weston's other writings on the history of fascism and the Spanish Revolution, which provide the historical case studies that ground the theoretical claim. The argument continues in IDOM's coverage of the Syrian war, the Ukraine conflict, and the COVID-19 pandemic, where the same logic of capitalist barbarism is traced through each new crisis. Readers should also consult the Against the Stream episode on primitive accumulation and the IDOM series on the tendency of the rate of profit to fall, which provides the economic mechanism underlying the political horrors described here.

Connections

  • Marx, Capital Volume I, Part VIII — the foundational text on primitive accumulation, which the article treats as ongoing, not historical.
  • Trotsky, The History of the Russian Revolution — for the theory of uneven and combined development and the role of violence in capitalist modernisation.
  • Lenin, Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism — for the analysis of how capitalist competition drives war and colonial domination.
  • Rosa Luxemburg, The Accumulation of Capital — for the argument that capitalism requires non-capitalist spaces to absorb its surplus, and destroys them in the process.
  • IDOM, "The Tendency of the Rate of Profit to Fall" — for the economic logic that compels capital toward ever more destructive forms of crisis management.

Key Quotes

  1. "Capitalism is not a system that has occasionally produced horrors. Horror is its very essence. It is a system that is based on the exploitation of the many by the few, and it has always used violence, both direct and structural, to maintain itself."

  2. "The idea that capitalism has become more civilised over time is a myth that serves to obscure the fact that the same predatory logic that drove the slave trade and colonial conquest continues to operate today, albeit in different forms."

  3. "The Greek people were told that there was no alternative to austerity. But this was not a technical economic necessity; it was a political choice made by the capitalist class to defend its profits at the expense of the living standards of millions."

  4. "Fascism is not an accident or a temporary madness. It is the logical outcome of a system that, when faced with a challenge to its rule, will resort to any means necessary to maintain its power."

  5. "The refugee crisis is not a humanitarian problem to be managed; it is the direct product of imperialist wars and the destruction of entire regions by the great powers in their competition for markets and resources."

  6. "Those who believe that capitalism can be reformed out of its barbarism have misunderstood the nature of the beast. The only way to end the horror is to abolish the system that produces it."