Skip to content

The spectre of Marxism

Marxist Analysis · 2026-05-13

Core Argument

The article argues that Marxism has not only survived the triumphalist declarations of its death following the collapse of the Stalinist regimes but is undergoing a significant revival, driven by the objective failures of capitalism itself. The central thesis is that the 2007–8 financial crash, the subsequent weak and debt-dependent recovery, and the unprecedented growth of inequality have exposed the hollowness of neoliberal capitalism and the intellectual bankruptcy of its apologists. The renewed interest in Marx's work — exemplified by the popularity of Thomas Piketty's Capital in the Twenty-First Century — is presented not as an academic curiosity but as a symptom of capitalism's systemic crisis and the growing attraction of Marxist analysis among layers of the youth and working class. The article claims that Marxism's explanatory power, particularly its analysis of capitalist crisis, exploitation, and the concentration of wealth, is more relevant today than at any point in the last century and a half.

Theoretical Grounding

The analysis draws on classical Marxist political economy, specifically Marx's theory of capitalist crisis as developed across the three volumes of Capital. The article implicitly invokes the tendency of the rate of profit to fall and the related phenomenon of overaccumulation when it describes capitalist growth since 1974 as "based on debts and credit" that "hollowed out the system." This is a reference to the growing role of fictitious capital — credit, debt, and financial speculation — as a temporary counter-tendency to the falling rate of profit, which ultimately produced the 2007–8 crash. The piece also relies on Lenin's theory of imperialism, noting the "titanic power of the monopolies and corporate capital" and their ability to manipulate governments and commodity prices. The rejection of Stalinism as a bureaucratic degeneration of the workers' state, rather than a failure of Marxism itself, is a settled position of the Trotskyist tradition from which the RCI emerges. The article also positions dialectical materialism as the philosophical method underpinning Marx's scientific analysis of capitalism, distinguishing it from the eclectic and impotent "post-modern" doctrines it dismisses.

Conjunctural Relevance

The article was written in May 2014, six years after the global financial crash and at a moment when the "recovery" in the advanced capitalist economies remained anaemic. The OECD countries had not returned to pre-crash growth trajectories, and the so-called BRICS economies — Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa — were experiencing sharply declining growth rates. The article cites the statistic that 85 individuals owned more wealth than half the global population, a figure that has since become even more extreme. The popularity of Piketty's book in 2014 is treated as a conjunctural signal: a bestseller in the US and Europe arguing that growing wealth concentration is "inherent to capitalism" represented a crack in the ideological hegemony of neoliberalism. The article also notes the mass movements and eruptions of the period — the Arab Spring, the Indignados in Spain, Occupy Wall Street — as evidence that class struggle was resurgent. The piece is situated in the immediate post-crash conjuncture when the intellectual and political certainties of the 1990s had been shattered but before the full consolidation of the authoritarian-populist turn in global politics.

Where the Argument Continues

The article is a broad-strokes polemic rather than a detailed theoretical elaboration. It does not develop the mechanics of the tendency of the rate of profit to fall or explain precisely how fictitious capital and debt acted as counter-tendencies after 1974. It also does not address the political strategy required to translate renewed interest in Marxism into revolutionary organisation — a question that the RCI has taken up extensively in other IDOM articles and Against the Current episodes. The relationship between the "spectre of Marxism" as an ideological phenomenon and the concrete tasks of building a revolutionary party in the current conjuncture is left open. Readers should consult the RCI's analyses of the 2008 crash, their writings on the nature of the Chinese bureaucracy, and their strategic assessments of the mass movements of 2011–14 for the fuller argument. The article also does not engage with the limitations of Piketty's framework — his reformist proposal for a global wealth tax and his refusal to draw revolutionary conclusions — which the RCI has critiqued in subsequent pieces.

Connections

  • Marx, Capital (especially Volume 3) — for the theory of the falling rate of profit and crisis.
  • Lenin, Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism — for the analysis of monopoly capital and financialisation.
  • Trotsky, The Revolution Betrayed — for the critique of Stalinism as bureaucratic degeneration.
  • IDOM articles on the 2008 crash — for the detailed economic analysis of the crisis.
  • IDOM critiques of Piketty — for the Marxist response to reformist analyses of inequality.
  • Against the Current episodes on the conjuncture — for the strategic perspective on building revolutionary organisation.

Key Quotes

  1. "Since the historic slump of 1974 capitalist growth has been based on debts and credit. This hollowed out the system and the debts started to accumulate leading to biggest financial crash in its history when the bubble burst in 2007-8."

  2. "Just eighty five people own and control more wealth than half of the total population on this planet. There is poverty on a biblical scale in large swathes of the world's territories and more people are forced into the abyss of misery, poverty and deprivation than ever before."

  3. "However the three volumes of Marx's 'Das Kapital' are not just about inequality. On the contrary they explain rise of capitalism, its fundamental core modus operandi of exploitation, the path to alienation and class struggle culminating in socialist revolutions as the only way-out of this oppressive and desecrating system."

  4. "At the present time the titanic power of the monopolies and corporate capital exercises a total stranglehold on the planet. With access to staggering sums of money and economies of gigantic proportions, with the ability to manipulate commodity prices and crushing powers to determine the policies of governments, they are the real masters of the world."

  5. "In the opening lines of 'The Communist Manifesto', Marx and Engels wrote in 1848, 'The spectre of Communism haunts Europe.' In the present rapidly-changing epoch the 'spectre of Marxism' is now beginning to haunt the world."