Skip to content

Stock market booms and the insanity of capitalism

Marxist Analysis · 2020-08-18

Core Argument

The article argues that the sharp divergence between collapsing real economic activity and soaring stock market valuations during the COVID-19 pandemic is not an anomaly or a sign of recovery, but a logical expression of capitalism's underlying crisis of overproduction. The stock market boom is a symptom of fictitious capital run amok — capitalists, unable to profitably invest in productive capacity due to saturated markets, instead gamble on financial assets. The central claim is that this irrational dynamic is not a malfunction but the normal operation of a system driven by profit rather than social need.

Theoretical Grounding

The analysis is rooted in Marx's distinction between the real economy — where value is created through the application of labour in production — and the sphere of circulation, where value is merely redistributed. It draws directly on Marx's concept of fictitious capital: money thrown into circulation without any equivalent in commodities, representing claims on future, unrealised surplus value. The article also implicitly invokes the Marxist theory of crisis, specifically the crisis of overproduction, in which capital cannot find sufficient outlets for productive investment because markets are saturated. The tendency toward monopoly is also deployed, showing how a handful of giant firms dominate stock indices while smaller capitals are crushed. The argument sits firmly within the classical Marxist tradition that treats financial speculation not as a separate sphere but as an organic outgrowth of contradictions in production.

Conjunctural Relevance

The article was written in September 2020, at the height of the first wave of the pandemic's economic devastation. It cites specific data: global equity prices rose 6.7 percent between July and early September 2020, the largest advance in over three decades. The S&P 500 reached a new all-time high on 18 August 2020, while tens of millions were thrown out of work and entire industries — tourism, hospitality, aviation — were decimated. The article also notes the sharp sell-off on 3 September 2020, when the Nasdaq fell 5 percent in a single day, as an early warning sign of bubble fragility. The concentration of the rally in a handful of tech giants — Apple reaching a $2 trillion market capitalisation, the "Big Five" tech firms accounting for nearly a quarter of the S&P 500's value — is identified as a reflection of monopoly capitalism's intensification under crisis conditions. The context of near-zero and negative interest rates, driven by central bank quantitative easing, is identified as the material basis driving capital out of bonds and into speculative assets.

Where the Argument Continues

The article is a relatively short, popular exposition. It does not develop a detailed analysis of the mechanisms by which central bank policy inflates asset prices, nor does it explore the long-term consequences of fictitious capital accumulation for the rate of profit. These themes are taken up in other IDOM articles on quantitative easing, the tendency of the rate of profit to fall, and the relationship between financialisation and stagnation. The argument also points toward the political conclusion — nationalisation without compensation — which is elaborated in the RCI's broader programme for a socialist transition. Readers should consult IDOM's series on the 2008 crisis and its aftermath, as well as articles on the Marxist theory of crisis and the nature of fictitious capital, for a fuller treatment.

Connections

  • Marx, Capital Volume 3, Part V — on interest-bearing capital and fictitious capital
  • Hilferding, Finance Capital — on the fusion of industrial and banking capital
  • IDOM articles on the 2008 financial crisis and the long downturn
  • IDOM articles on quantitative easing and central bank policy
  • The RCI's programme for the expropriation of the monopolies

Key Quotes

  1. "The buying and selling of stocks and shares is what Karl Marx described as 'fictitious capital'. This is where money is thrown into circulation without any equivalent in values — that is, without any commodity production or genuine productive activity."

  2. "Marx described how the ultimate fantasy of the capitalists was to make money out of money: financial alchemy, without the bother of human labour, investment in machinery, or even production itself."

  3. "The circus of speculation might seem absurd and irrational. But this is the logical result of a system built on profit and competition."

  4. "At root, the rally in global stock markets is another symptom of the enormous crisis of overproduction; of the saturation in the world market."

  5. "The stock exchange is largely divorced from the state of the real economy, hence the recent booms while the economy tanks."

  6. "The gambling and speculation on the stock exchange is of no use to society. Instead, the stock market is just a giant casino, where the wealth produced by the working class is siphoned off by the parasites and fat cats."