- Home
- Current issue
- Past issues
- Archive
- Maps
- Blog
- Podcast
- Follow us
- About ‘It’s not employers who are clamouring for immigration; it’s the economy’
What France’s far right has learned from Israel’s apartheid system¶
There are regular warnings that France risks succumbing to fascism. But Mussolini’s Italy may not be the model that attracts the far right; it could be Binyamin Netanyahu’s de facto apartheid state.
Amidall the speculation on the left about the future of French politics, one prediction has crowded out all others for the past two decades: we’re heading towards fascism. In the late 2000s, Nicolas Sarkozy’s cult of the police, his law-and-order obsession and his targeting of young people from immigrant backgrounds – ‘scum’ to be cleaned up ‘with a Kärcher’, as he famously said – prompted widespread criticism.
Then, around 2015-16, Islamist terrorist attacks, panic over ‘radicalised youth’ and an influx of refugees from the Middle East helped to entrench, in the eyes of some, the idea of an ‘enemy within’, ready to strike at the Republic with the complicity of a section of the left.
A further step came with François Hollande’s proposal to strip French-born dual nationals of their citizenship if convicted of ‘a crime constituting a serious attack on the life of the nation’. With the repression of social movements, the media’s normalisation of subjects once confined to conservatism’s furthest fringes, the National Rally’s (RN) almost uninterrupted advance during Emmanuel Macron’s two terms and business leaders warming towards the party, what began as a hypothesis has turned into a certainty: fascism is taking hold in France.
Undeniably, invoking Mussolini’s regime and the 1930s gets attention. It presupposes a lurch towards authoritarianism if the far right comes to power as a result of traditional parties conceding the terms of political debate to their opponents. So, this line of argument goes, what is required is action while there is still time, inspired by famous anti-fascist struggles of the past, even unsuccessful ones.
Towards legalised segregation?¶
Yet does the spectre of fascism conceal a less dramatic but much more concrete danger? That of an almost imperceptible slide towards a system of legalised segregation in which, as in Israel, part of the population, classed as alien in origin, would be disciplined (…)
This article can be read by subscribers¶
Benoît Bréville&Pierre Rimbert
(1)See Michael J Sandel,What Money Can’t Buy: The Moral Limits of Markets, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, New York, 2012.
(2)See Hartmut Rosa,Social Acceleration: A New Theory of Modernity, Columbia University Press, 2015.
Share this article¶
Topstories¶
- The newspaperFollow usNewsletterContact usThe team
- The newspaper
The newspaper¶
- Follow us
- Newsletter
- Contact us
- The team
- ServicesSubscriptionsInstitutional subscriptionsDonationsConfidentiality policy
- Services
Services¶
- Subscriptions
- Institutional subscriptions
- Donations
- Confidentiality policy
- About usWho we areFind LMDInternational editionsFriends of LMD
- About us
About us¶
- Who we are
- Find LMD
- International editions
- Friends of LMD
- Le Monde diplomatiqueArchivesPodcastBlogMaps
- Le Monde diplomatique
Le Monde diplomatique¶
- Archives
- Podcast
- Blog
- Maps